Breastfeeding is a beautiful and natural process, allowing mothers to nourish their children and create a unique bond. But as with most parenting choices, it’s not without controversy—especially when it extends beyond what’s considered the “typical” timeline.
A mother in Australia, Lauren McLeod, sparked an online storm after sharing her experience breastfeeding her son until he was six years old. Adding fuel to the fire, she also defended drinking alcohol while breastfeeding, a topic that remains highly debated.
So, where should the line be drawn? Is extended breastfeeding acceptable? And what does science say about alcohol and breastfeeding? Let’s unpack the controversy and explore both sides of the story.
The Mother’s Perspective: Breastfeeding Beyond the Norm
Lauren McLeod, a 31-year-old mother from Perth, Australia, has two children: Bowie, 7, and Tigerlily, 4. While Bowie recently stopped breastfeeding at age six, Lauren continues to nurse Tigerlily and has no immediate plans to stop.
For Lauren, breastfeeding is about listening to her children’s needs. She champions a philosophy known as child-led weaning, where the child decides when they are ready to stop nursing.
“I’m just like any other mom doing the best for my children,” Lauren shared. When her son finally weaned, she even celebrated the milestone with a “bye-bye boobie” party, complete with cake and heartfelt closure for both.
While many may find the practice unusual, extended breastfeeding is not unheard of. In fact, organizations like the World Health Organization (WHO) recommend breastfeeding for at least two years, stating that there’s no harm in continuing beyond that if both mother and child are willing.
For Lauren, it’s about comfort, nutrition, and the bond breastfeeding brings. But not everyone agrees.
Why Extended Breastfeeding Sparks Controversy
Extended breastfeeding often raises eyebrows, particularly in societies where it’s considered unconventional or unnecessary past infancy. Here’s why it causes such heated debate:
- Societal Norms: In many cultures, breastfeeding older children is seen as unusual or even inappropriate. Once a child can walk, talk, and eat solid foods, public opinion often leans toward weaning.
- Misconceptions: Critics argue that extended breastfeeding may hinder a child’s independence, though no scientific evidence supports this.
- Lack of Awareness: Extended breastfeeding is normal in many parts of the world, yet stigma persists in Western societies due to misinformation and societal expectations.
At its core, the debate is often about discomfort with something that challenges the norm, rather than actual harm or risk.
The Alcohol and Breastfeeding Debate: What Science Says
Lauren McLeod also faced criticism for occasionally drinking alcohol while breastfeeding. For many, the very idea sounds shocking, as people assume alcohol passes directly into breast milk. However, the science tells a more nuanced story.
Here’s what you need to know:
- Minimal Transfer of Alcohol: Studies show that alcohol passes into breast milk in very small amounts—typically less than 2% of the alcohol consumed by the mother. The levels peak about 30 to 60 minutes after drinking and decline as the alcohol leaves the bloodstream.
- Moderation Is Key: The CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) states that moderate alcohol consumption (one standard drink) is unlikely to harm a breastfeeding baby. Waiting 2-3 hours per drink before breastfeeding can further minimize any risk.
- Myths and Reality: The assumption that alcohol makes breast milk unsafe or that it “gets the baby drunk” is rooted in misinformation. In reality, drinking responsibly while breastfeeding poses little to no danger when done in moderation.
Lauren addressed this directly, saying: “Many people probably assume that alcohol goes straight into breast milk and will make the baby ‘drunk’. That’s absolutely not the case.”
By staying informed and drinking responsibly, mothers can safely breastfeed without guilt or unnecessary fear.
What Do Experts Say About Extended Breastfeeding?
Extended breastfeeding remains a personal choice, but experts agree that it has several benefits for both mother and child:
- Nutritional Benefits: Breast milk continues to provide essential vitamins, minerals, and immune-boosting properties, even as children grow older.
- Emotional Comfort: Nursing can help children feel safe, secure, and bonded to their mother, especially during stressful times.
- Health Advantages: Breastfeeding reduces the mother’s risk of developing certain cancers, osteoporosis, and cardiovascular issues.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and World Health Organization (WHO) both affirm that there’s no upper age limit for breastfeeding. As long as it works for the family, extended breastfeeding is entirely acceptable.
Why Judgment Persists in Parenting Choices
The backlash against Lauren McLeod highlights a broader issue: the persistent judgment parents face for decisions that stray from the norm.
Whether it’s breastfeeding duration, sleep routines, or diet choices, mothers are often criticized for not conforming to societal expectations. However, parenting is deeply personal, and what works for one family may not work for another.
Lauren’s response to her critics is a reminder that mothers should feel empowered to trust their instincts, educate themselves, and do what’s best for their children—without fear of judgment.
Balancing Education and Respect for Parenting Choices
While Lauren’s choices may not resonate with everyone, they open up an important conversation about:
- Parent Autonomy: Parents should have the freedom to make informed decisions without unnecessary scrutiny.
- Education Over Judgment: Instead of criticizing practices like drinking while breastfeeding, it’s more productive to spread accurate information about safety and moderation.
- Breaking Stigmas: Extended breastfeeding and responsible alcohol consumption aren’t harmful when approached knowledgeably. Breaking outdated misconceptions can lead to healthier, more open conversations.
Conclusion: Respect, Education, and Open Conversations Are Key
Lauren McLeod’s decision to breastfeed her son until he was six and her stance on drinking while nursing may challenge societal norms, but they highlight an important truth: parenting isn’t one-size-fits-all.
Breastfeeding—whether for six months or six years—is a personal choice with proven benefits. Similarly, consuming alcohol in moderation while nursing is supported by science as safe.
Ultimately, we should strive for respectful dialogue and informed decision-making rather than judgment. Parents, like Lauren, deserve the freedom to raise their children in the way that works best for their families. In a world quick to criticize, let’s remember that understanding and support go much further than condemnation.
